5

4 Most Ridiculous Theories about the Tunguska Event!

‘I was sitting in the porch of the house at the trading station of Vanovara at 7 a.m. and looking towards the north . . . suddenly the sky appeared like it was split in two, high above the forest, the whole northern sky appeared to be completely covered with blazing fire. At that moment I felt a great wave of heat as if my shirt had caught fire… after a minute, there was a loud bang in the sky, and I could hear a mighty crash. Subsequently, I was fiercely thrown to the ground about 5-6 meters away from the house and for a minute or two I lost my consciousness.”

Farmer Sergei Semenov is only one of the few people who witnessed the Tunguska event on June 30, 1908, and survived. At the time of explosion, he was having a breakfast in trade station of Vanovara, located approximately 40 miles from the epicentre. What actually happened on that day? Early in the morning, on Tuesday 30.th of June 1908, there was a massive explosion in the area of Podkamennaya Tunguska, an unprecedented event uncomparable to anything in our modern history.

https://c479107.ssl.cf2.rackcdn.com/files/26234/area14mp/xkh376v7-1372241498.jpg

Aftermath of the 1908 Tunguska event

Closest seismograph, installed in Irkutsk, 600 miles from the epicentre, recorded strong vibrations lasting more than 60 minutes. Sound wave caused by the event encircled the planet multiple times. More than 800 kilometers away, in the city of Kansk, the noise was so loud that a train engineer stopped his train, thinking that one of the freight cars had exploded, and about 800 square miles of forests were flattened by the shockwave. However, any remnants of the object which caused this event are yet to be found.

According to the widely accepted theory, Tunguska event was caused by an asteroid air-burst on a grandiose scale(similar to 2013 Chelyabinsk event), which produced more than 30 megatons of energy.

http://olkhov.narod.ru/tungus1.jpg

Near the epicenter of Tunguska event(2008)

Both existing evidence and majority of scientists support this theory, however, soon after the explosion, incredible amount of other theories appeared, trying to explain the true nature of the Tunguska event. They range from scientifically based theories, supported by solid evidence, to various irrational hypotheses, often fabricated just to get attention. Let’s explore some of the other theories about the Tunguska Event, from scientific to plain ridiculous, and find out what really exploded in Siberia in year 1908.

4.Cometary Air-Burst

”Mathematical models indicate, that Tunguska event was actually caused by an explosion of small comet”, Moscow University professor Samuel Grigoryan claimed in year 1976.”Core of the comet is composed of frozen gasses, ice and cosmic dust. During its passage through the atmosphere, it would be rapidly heated, causing immediate evaporation and explosion. Released energy would correspond to the estimated 40 megatons”.

http://d1jqu7g1y74ds1.cloudfront.net/wp-content/uploads/2009/03/tunguska2.jpg

Visualisation of the Tunguska explosion

Although this theory, first suggested in 1930 by British meteorologist Francis Whipple, explains the strange luminous phenomena observed by the eyewitnesses of the Tunguska event, majority of scientists consider it being very improbable. They often point out that a fragile cometary body ought to have already disintegrated in the uppermost layers of the atmosphere, whilst the object that caused the event apparently remained intact until it reached the lower atmospheric layers.

3.Collision with a miniature black hole, or piece of antimatter

According to many so-called ”experts”, Tunguska explosion was supposedly caused by annihilation, physical process that occurs when a subatomic particle collides with its respective antiparticle of the opposite charge, producing immense amounts of energy. According to this theory, first suggested in year 1941 by Lincoln LaPaz, the Tunguska event was likely caused by the annihilation of a chunk of antimatter colliding with Earth.

Although the antimatter theory explains the observed luminous phenomena, and why no remnants of asteroid or comet were found in the area, existence of such large antimatter chunks is often deemed being teoretically impossible. In addition, annihilation of the alleged chunk of antimatter would probably happen in the uppermost atmospheric levels.

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/d4/BlackHole.jpg

Did a miniature black hole really cause the Tunguska event?

Another speculative hypothesis suggests, that the 1908 Siberian explosion was caused by a small black hole passing through Earth. This hypothesis was first formulated in year 1973 by American scientists Albert A. Jackson and Michael P. Ryan. However, as there was no exit event(second explosion, occuring as the black hole shot out in the North Atlantic), this hypothesis is considered wrong by majority of modern scientists. Other evidence, as dust trails and high-nickel concentrations around the impact area also dismiss this hypothesis.

2.Intervention of Agda, God of Thunder

Akulina, an Evenki woman, who was closer than 20 miles to epicentre at the time of explosion, later reported the event to the scientists: ”A mighty wind flattened our tent, while we had been sleeping. A brilliant ourburst of light blinded us, the wind was breaking trees like they were sticks. As a rising whirlwind lifted us off the ground, I lost conciousness”. After she woke up, she remembers seeking her husband, Ivan, being lifted up by blast, and slammed into one of the remaining upright trees, 130 feet from the remnants of the camp they had slept in. He died few hours later from fractures, shock and blood loss. ”Our reindeers also vanished, and we haven’t found them since”, Akulina also reported.

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/f/f4/Evenk.jpg

Group of Evenki people

If we can believe shamans of the Evenki tribe, who lived in the area for thousands of years, Tunguska event was caused by the Agda, the God of Thunder himself. Dissatisfied by the tribal disputes, Agda reputedly sent ”demons with shining eyes and fiery tails”, to punish the disobedient Evenki men.

Of course, we can’t take this explanation seriously. However, the fact remains that immediately after the event, the area was declared sacred and forbidden zone by Evenki tribesmen, who then reportedly expelled or killed dozens of Soviet scientific expeditions that ventured into the area of explosion decades after.

1.UFO Explosion

In year 1956, Russian sci-fi writer Alexander Kazancev published his short novel titled ”The Explosion”, with his own explanation about the true cause of the explosion. According to his version of the story, the Tunguska event was caused by the massive nuclear explosion of an extraterrestrial spaceship.

In year 1945, eleven years before the published the famous story, Kazantsev visited the ruins of the Hiroshima, city devastated by a nuclear explosion. Near the explosion’s epicenter, he noticed still-standing trees, with their leaves and branches ripped off by the sheer force of pressure wave. 6 years later, during his visit to Tunguska, he noticed similar patterns; no crater and standing trees without any branches or leaves. Because of that, he quickly comes to a conclusion; 1908 event had to be caused by a massive explosion, probably of nuclear origin.

File:Tunguska event fallen trees.jpg

Aftermath of the Tunguska explosion, (1929 explosion)

Another thing supporting the nuclear explosion theory are the burn marks on all trees around the epicenter. Forest fire caused by meteor explosion would burn the trees all around, however, marks only on one side indicate concentrated, short-term radiation heat, as during a nuclear explosion.

This hypothesis was further expanded by Valery Uvarov, director of the International UFO Network himself. Quoting his works: ”In northwestern Yakutia in Siberia, in the basin of the Upper Viliuy River, there is a hard-to-reach area, bearing the marks of tremendous cataclysm that took place some 800 years ago. Distributed across this area are mysterious metal objects located deep underground in the permafrost. The last time that this installation shot down a meteor was on 24/25 September last year.”

Read more: Top 10 Mysterious Artifacts

 

2

15 Ridiculous Predictions Which Didn’t Come True! – Part 3

http://pxwallpaper.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/11/4603.jpg

“The proposition that the Earth is not the center of the world and immovable but that it moves, and also with a diurnal motion, is equally absurd and false philosophically and theologically. It will never be proven that Earth moves.” (Papal Inquisition to Galileo, 1633)

“The most important fundamental laws and facts of physical science shave all been discovered, and are so firmly established that the possibility of their ever being supplanted in consequence of new experimental discoveries is incredibly remote.” (1907 Nobel Prize winner Albert Abraham Michelson, 1890)

“That so-called space travel is utter bilge” (Astronomer Richard Wooley, 1956)

Anyone who expects some source of power from the transformation of the atom is talking moonshine.” (Ernest Rutherford, 1934)

“Medicinal applications of radiation will be slowly removed from the hands of professionals. Doctors will only write you a prescription, and then you will go to radiologist’s shop just near drugstore where you will be then given appropriate radiation treatment. Radiation is the ultimate cure to all ilnesses.” (J.B.S.Haldane, 1943)

Atomic energy might be as good as our present-day explosives, but it is very unlikely to produce anything more dangerous.” (Winston Churchill, 1939)

“The radio waves that I discovered are of no use whatsoever.” (Heinrich Hertz, 1887)

“War is a relic of babarism, probably destined to become as obsolete as duelling” (William Thompson, lord Kelvin, 1907)

“The escape from pain in surgical operations is only a fantasy… Knife and pain are two words which will be always inseparable in the minds of patients.” (Alfred-Armand-Louis-Marie Velpeau, 1839)

“These so-called X-rays are only a deliberate hoax” (William Thompson, lord Kelvin, 1895)

“Cars will cost as little as $200. People will have two-month vacation. They will care little for possessions. The happiest people will live in one-factory villages. (Predictions for 1960 by General Motors, 1939)

Who the hell wants to hear actors talk? (H.M.Warner, 1927)

The cinema is only a little more than a fad. It’s canned drama. Actuall, what audiences really want to see is flesh and blood on the stage. (Charlie Chaplin, 1916)

No one will pay money to get from Berlin to Potsdam by train in one hour when he can ride his horse there in one day for free. (King William I of Prussia, 1864)

It is unknowable how long the Iraq War will last. It could last six days, six weeks. I doubt six months. (Donald Rumsfeld, 2003)

Facebook

European & World History

Visit Us On TwitterVisit Us On FacebookCheck Our Feed